How to Pick Lube for Anal Play: Boy Butter vs Elbow Grease
By Tantus Inc. Good Clean Fun | Published: 2026-11-05
Category: 사용 방법 가이드
Learn how to choose between Boy Butter Original and Elbow Grease Cream for anal play by matching thickness, cleanup, and packaging to your needs.
Quick answer
For most people trying anal play, start with Boy Butter Original in the 9 oz squeeze tube: its coconut oil and silicone blend stays slick and rinses off skin and fabric with water alone. Choose Elbow Grease Cream Original if you prefer a mineral oil-based cream that coats quickly and comes in a large 15 oz tub for repeat use.
Why thickness and base ingredients change the experience
Thick lubes and cream lubes both aim to reduce friction, but they feel different in use. Boy Butter Original is homogenized like real butter, so it holds its shape and stays where you apply it. Elbow Grease Cream is smooth and creamy, spreading easily to coat the area quickly. Neither product lists a fragrance-free claim or condom compatibility on the label, so check the packaging if those are priorities.
Cleanup and fabric safety: water vs. detergent
Boy Butter Original washes off with water alone from skin and fabric, which simplifies cleanup after anal play. Elbow Grease Cream contains mineral oil and petrolatum, so it may require soap and water or a detergent pre-treatment on fabric. If you want the lowest-effort cleanup, the water-rinsable option has a clear advantage.
Squeeze tube vs. tub: which packaging suits your routine
A squeeze tube like Boy Butter Original lets you dispense lube directly without dipping fingers, which can be more hygienic and easier to control during play. A tub like Elbow Grease Cream offers a larger quantity and a lower cost per ounce, but you need clean hands or a spoon to scoop it out. Consider where you store your lube and how often you play to decide which format fits better.
How to choose your lube for anal play
- Decide on thickness and texture: If you want a lube that stays put and feels like butter, choose Boy Butter Original. If you prefer a smooth cream that spreads easily, choose Elbow Grease Cream. Common mistake: assuming thicker is always better—some people find very thick lubes harder to spread. Test a small amount on your skin first to see how the texture feels.
- Check cleanup preferences: Boy Butter Original washes off with water alone, while Elbow Grease Cream may need soap and water or a detergent pre-treatment on fabric. Common mistake: using oil-based lubes with latex condoms without verifying compatibility—check the label. Keep a dedicated towel nearby to catch drips and simplify cleanup.
- Choose your packaging format: Pick the 9 oz squeeze tube if you want mess-free dispensing and easy travel. Pick the 15 oz tub if you prefer a larger quantity for home use and don't mind scooping. Common mistake: storing lube in a hot place—both products can change consistency. Store your lube at room temperature and away from direct sunlight.
- Consider your budget and frequency: Elbow Grease Cream offers more volume per dollar, making it a practical choice for frequent users. Boy Butter Original costs more per ounce but may last longer per application due to its thick texture. Common mistake: buying a large tub before trying the formula. Start with a smaller size if you are unsure which texture you prefer.
Product facts
- Boy Butter Original 9 oz Squeeze: Boy Butter Original is an oil-based lubricant made from coconut oil and an organic silicone blend, homogenized like real butter. The thick, butter-like texture stays in place during anal play and rinses off with water alone.
Boy Butter Original 9 oz Squeeze - Elbow Grease Cream Original Formula – 15 Oz.: Elbow Grease Cream Original Formula is a mineral oil-based cream that has been made since 1979 and comes in a 15 oz tub. The large tub provides a long-lasting supply of smooth, creamy lube that coats quickly for friction-free use.
Elbow Grease Cream Original Formula – 15 Oz.
